Loading...
Showing posts with label management. Show all posts
Showing posts with label management. Show all posts

Warren Buffett’s hires New Investor

Warren Buffett today announced that Todd Combs, a 39-year old investment manager of Castle Point Capital, has joined Berkshire Hathaway to help manage the company’s investment portfolio.

“For three years, Charlie Munger and I have been looking for someone of Todd’s caliber to handle a significant portion of Berkshire’s investment portfolio. We are delighted that Todd will be joining us.”

Todd Combs owns the following companies in his financially-focused fund; U.S. Bancorp, MasterCard Inc, State Street Corp, The Western Union Company and CME Group Inc. His portfolio is concentrated in financials with more than 70% invested.

I trust in Warren Buffett’s choice, so it will be interesting to see what this young new executive can do.

Investing like Warren Buffett | Part 3

Part 3 of our Investing like Warren Buffett series discusses his 1979 Chairman’s letter to shareholders of Berkshire Hathaway Inc. Let’s see what important investment advice he leaves with us this year.

Click here for 1979 Chairman’s Letter to Shareholders

 

“The primary test of managerial economic performance is the achievement of a high earnings rate on equity capital employed (without undue leverage, accounting gimmickry, etc.) and not the achievement of consistent gains in earnings per share.”

On Long Term Results

It is more important to pay attention to the long term results of stock ownership, rather than the short term performance. Unrealized gains or losses from stock ownership should be viewed different from the actual earnings from operations.

“In measuring long term economic performance - in contrast to yearly performance - we believe it is appropriate to recognize fully any realized capital gains or losses as well as extraordinary items, and also to utilize financial statements presenting equity securities at market value. Such capital gains or losses, either realized or unrealized, are fully as important to shareholders over a period of years as earnings realized in a more routine manner through operations; it is just that their impact is often extremely capricious in the short run, a characteristic that makes them inappropriate as an indicator of single year managerial performance.”

 

Be aware of those asset-intensive businesses with great economics, they may not always be great investments. Sometimes, a simple business is the better choice.

“In some businesses - a network TV station, for example - it is virtually impossible to avoid earning extraordinary returns on tangible capital employed in the business. And assets in such businesses sell at equally extraordinary prices, one thousand cents or more on the dollar, a valuation reflecting the splendid, almost unavoidable, economic results obtainable. Despite a fancy price tag, the “easy” business may be the better route to go.”

 

“We can speak from experience, having tried the other route. Your Chairman made the decision a few years ago to purchase Waumbec Mills in Manchester, New Hampshire, thereby expanding our textile commitment. By any statistical test, the purchase price was an extraordinary bargain; we bought well below the working capital of the business and, in effect, got very substantial amounts of machinery and real estate for less than nothing. But the purchase was a mistake. While we labored mightily, new problems arose as fast as old problems were tamed.”


On Turnarounds;

“Both our operating and investment experience cause us to conclude that “turnarounds” seldom turn, and that the same energies and talent are much better employed in a good business purchased at a fair price than in a poor business purchased at a bargain price.”


On attracting shareholders that have similar expectations through communication and policies;

“In large part, companies obtain the shareholder constituency that they seek and deserve. If they focus their thinking and communications on short-term results or short-term stock market consequences they will, in large part, attract shareholders who focus on the same factors.  And if they are cynical in their treatment of investors, eventually that cynicism is highly likely to be returned by the investment community.”


“Phil Fisher, a respected investor and author, once likened the policies of the corporation in attracting shareholders to those of a restaurant attracting potential customers. A restaurant could seek a given clientele - patrons of fast foods, elegant dining, Oriental food, etc. - and eventually obtain an appropriate group of devotees. If the job were expertly done, that clientele, pleased with the service, menu, and price level offered, would return consistently. But the restaurant could not change its character constantly and end up with a happy and stable clientele. If the business vacillated between French cuisine and take-out chicken, the result would be a revolving door of confused and dissatisfied customers.”


Lessons learned from this report:

  1. Think long term when it comes to investing.
  2. Buy businesses that are simple and easy to understand.
  3. It is better to buy a good business at a fair price than a poor business at a bargain price.
  4. Look for management that are honest and consistent in the communication and policies.

Related Articles
Invest Like Warren Buffett Part 1>>
Invest Like Warren Buffett Part 2>>

Notes from Berkshire Hathaway Annual Shareholders Meeting

BuffettShareholdersMeeting Notes on Berkshire Hathaway Annual Shareholders Meeting From Reuters and GuruFocus

Q1 Operating Results and Book Value
Buffett told a record crowd at a somber annual meeting of his Berkshire Hathaway Inc that first-quarter operating profit fell and the company's book value declined 6 percent, as the recession weighed on many of the company's businesses and investments.
Operating profit fell about 12 percent from a year earlier to $1.7 billion, as most of Berkshire's businesses were "basically down," Buffett told an estimated 35,000 people at the meeting in downtown Omaha.

The decline in book value results in part from falling stock prices and higher losses on derivatives contracts, and comes on top of a 9.6 percent decline last year, the biggest drop since Buffett began running the company in 1965.


Predict Gloomy Economy but Stimulate Activity Working
Buffett offered a gloomy forecast for parts of the U.S. economy and Berkshire itself, though he said massive federal efforts to stimulate activity could pay off at a possible cost of higher inflation.

"It has been a very extraordinary year," Buffett said. "When the American public pulls back the way they have, the government does need to step in.... It is the right thing to do, but it won't be a free ride."


Housing Prices, Retailers and Newspapers
Buffett said housing prices have yet to stabilize broadly, that retailers may be under pressure for a "considerable period of time," and that he would not buy most U.S. newspaper companies "at any price."


Insurance not as good
He also said that in insurance, which comprises about half of Berkshire's operations, the earnings power "was not as good last year as normal" and "won't be as good this year."


Succession
Buffett also said the four candidates to replace him as Berkshire's chief investment officer failed to outperform the Standard & Poor's 500 last year, but remained confident they could perform well over time. Berkshire still has three internal candidates to replace Buffett as chief executive.

Buffett declined to name the candidates to replace him as chief executive officer and chief investment officer, but said Ajit Jain, who runs much of his insurance businesses and whom investors believe is a CEO contender, is irreplaceable.

"It would be impossible to replace Ajit," he said. "We wouldn't give the latitude to size or risk that we would give to Ajit.... We won't find a substitute for him."

Buffett said that for any CEO candidate, "the biggest job they have will be to develop relationships with potential sellers of businesses."

But he added that while Berkshire is much less nimble than it was when it was smaller, "our sustainable competitive advantage is we have a culture and business model that people would find very, very difficult to copy."

Munger added: "The stupidity in the management practices of the rest of the corporate world will likely be ample enough to give this company some comparative advantage in the future."


No stock buyback
Berkshire 's stock has fallen 39 percent since December 2007, and profit last year fell 62 percent from a year earlier. Buffett said he would not buy back Berkshire stock now, because its share price is not "demonstrably below" the company's intrinsic value.


Derivatives
Much of the worry about Berkshire has focused on Buffett's use of derivatives in making long-term bets on the direction of stocks and junk bonds, and which have so far resulted in billions of dollars of paper losses.

While Buffett still expects the contracts tied to equity stock indexes to make money, he said "we have run into far more bankruptcies in the last year than is normal." He said he now expects the contracts tied to credit defaults will show a loss before investment income, and perhaps after as well.

Buffett still distinguishes his derivatives from others such as credit default swaps, given that he collects billions of dollars of premiums upfront to invest and posts little collateral. He called other derivatives "a danger to the system. There is no question about that."


Wells Fargo & US Bancorp
Buffett expressed confidence in Wells Fargo & Co, one of Berkshire's biggest investments, saying it has "by far the best competitive position" of any large U.S. bank.
He also said some banks will weather the credit crisis well, saying that if he wanted to turn Berkshire into a bank holding company, "I would love to buy all of US Bancorp, or I would love to buy all of Wells."


Moody’s
He also defended Berkshire's roughly 20 percent stake in Moody's Corp, a credit rating agency faulted for failing to predict the housing crisis and assigning high ratings to risky debt for too long.

"They made a huge mistake" but were not alone, Buffett said. "The rating agency business is probably still a good business, (but) it won't be doing the volume probably for a long time in certain areas of the capital markets."

Investing like Warren Buffett | Part 2

Part 2 of our Investing like Warren Buffett series discusses his 1978 Chairman’s letter to the shareholders of Berkshire Hathaway Inc. Since I am in the process of typing this and have not read it myself yet, I am excited to see what knowledge he had to impart on us at that stage of his life and investment career. This not only serves as great investment advice, but we are also able to learn how he analyzes businesses and what thought-processing went into picking the companies that became part of his investment portfolio.

I know we will also learn from his mistakes, which he is not shy about discussing in his letters as well. Let’s see what he has to share with us.

1978 Chairman’s letter to shareholders

Warren Buffett talks about investing in equity and his inability to predict stock market movements. What’s important is that he eludes to the fact that the equity holdings of his company will be worth a lot more than they paid, meaning that they were purchased with a significant margin of safety.

“We make no attempt to predict how security markets will behave; successfully forecasting short term stock price movements is something we think neither we nor anyone else can do. In the longer run, however, we feel that many of our major equity holdings are going to be worth considerably more money than we paid, and that investment gains will add significantly to the operating returns of the insurance group.”


Warren Buffett on textiles:

“Slow capital turnover, coupled with low profit margins on sales, inevitably produces inadequate returns on capital. Obvious approaches to improved profit margins involve differentiation of product, lowered manufacturing costs through more efficient equipment or better utilization of people, redirection toward fabrics enjoying stronger market trends, etc. Our management is diligently pursuing such objectives. The problem, of course, is that our competitors are just as diligently doing the same thing”

“The textile industry illustrates in textbook style how producers of relatively undifferentiated goods in capital intensive businesses must earn inadequate returns except under conditions of tight supply or real shortage.”


Warren Buffett again reiterates the criteria for selecting stocks for ownership. However, it is apparent that there are times where market prices do not offer great bargains.

”We get excited enough to commit a big percentage of insurance company net work to equities only when we find (1) businesses we can understand, (2) with favorable long-term prospects , (3) operated by honest and competent people, and (4) priced very attractively. We usually can identify a small number of potential investments meeting requirements (1), (2), (3), but (4) often prevents action.”

 

Buffett emphasizes that they will be net buyers of stocks in most years, therefore, as with any type of purchase, if you are the buyer, you would prefer to prices to be lower than higher. Therefore, this major principle is applied to stocks as well. The time to be buying is when prices are going down, not increasing.

“We are not concerned with whether the market quickly revalues upward securities that we believe are selling at bargain prices. In fact, we prefer just the opposite since, in most years, we expect to have funds available to be a net buyer of securities. And consistent attractive purchasing is likely to prove to be of more eventual benefit to us than any selling opportunities provided by a short-term run up in stock prices to levels at which we are unwilling to continue buying.”

 

Buffett on diversification. If you believe that a company has excellent future economics, he prefers to buy large quantities of that company, than allocating capital to many different companies.

“Our policy is to concentrate holdings. We try to avoid buying a little of this or that when we are only lukewarm about the business or its price. When we are convinced as to attractiveness, we believe in buying worthwhile amounts.”

 

Buffett talks about buying companies where management is already established.

“Of course, with a minor interest we do not have the right to direct or even influence management policies of SAFECO. But why should we wish to do this? The record would indicate that they do a better job of managing their operations than we could do ourselves. While there may be less excitement and prestige in sitting back and letting others do the work, we think that is all one loses by accepting a passive participation in excellent management. Because, quite clearly, if one controlled a company run as well as SAFECO, the proper policy also would be to sit back and let management do its job.”

 

Buffett on use of retained earnings, dividend payments and share repurchases.

“We are not at all unhappy when our wholly-owned businesses retain all of their earnings if they can utilize internally those funds at attractive rates. Why should we feel differently about retention of earnings by companies in which we hold small equity interests, but where the record indicates even better prospects for profitable employment of capital? (This proposition cuts the other way, of course, in industries with low capital requirements, or if management has a record of plowing capital into projects of low profitability; then earnings should be paid out or used to repurchase shares – often by far the most attractive option for capital utilization.)”

 

Another great report with some key points.
These are some points I learned from this report.

  1. Do not attempt to forecast stock market movements. Focus on the underlying business.
  2. Businesses with low capital turnover and low profit margins should be avoided as long-term investments.
  3. Investments could fit all your criteria upon analysis, however, if the price is not right, it does not make a good investment. Be patient.
  4. Management is very important when selecting businesses.

What have you gotten from this report.
Leave a comment.


Related Articles
Invest Like Warren Buffett Part 1>>

Investing like Warren Buffett | Part 1

Our new series will discuss the investing philosophy of Warren Buffett with direct excerpts from his Chairman’s letters to shareholders. As an investment student, this is a must read for all who intend to pursue such a feat. These letters are known to be one of the greatest sources of investment advice and is probably the most anticipated investment document each year.

We will start out series by studying and analyzing his letters all the way back to 1977 until present day. It may take us some time to do so, but I know at the end, we will have learned a great deal from this entire experience. Our investment I.Q. will surely raise several points, which is incentive enough to perform this task.

BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY (CLOCK TOWER)

Berkshire_Hathaway_clocktower

 

1977 Letter to Stockholders of Berkshire Hathaway

Warren Buffett on Earnings Per Share:

“Most companies define “record” earnings as a new high in earnings per share. Since businesses customarily add from year to year to their equity base, we find nothing particularly noteworthy in a management performance combining, say, a 10% increase in equity capital and a 5% increase in earnings per share. After all, even a totally dormant savings account will produce steadily rising interest rates earnings each year because of compounding."


What we, as investors, should be looking at:

“…we believe a more appropriate measure of managerial economic performance to be return on equity capital”.


Warren Buffett on long-term investing:

“…Most of our large stock positions are going to be held for many years and the scorecard on our investment decisions will be provided by business results over that period, and not by prices on any given day. Just as it would be foolish to focus unduly on short-term prospects when acquiring an entire company, we think it equally unsound to become mesmerized by prospective near term earnings or recent trends in earnings when purchasing small pieces of a company; i.e., marketable common stocks”.


Warren Buffett’s underlying investment philosophy has been the same since 1977. There is no significant difference in buying an entire company and buying shares of a company. Similar considerations must be made.

“We select our marketable equity securities in much the same way we would evaluate a business for acquisition in its entirety. We want the business to be (1) one that we understand, (2) with favorable long-term prospects, (3) operated by honest and competent people, and (4) available at a very attractive price. We ordinarily make no attempt to buy equities for anticipated favorable stock price behavior in the short term. In fact, if their business experience continues to satisfy us, we welcome lower market prices of stocks we own as an opportunity to acquire even more of a good thing at a better price.”

“Our experience has been that pro-rata portions of truly outstanding businesses sometimes sell in the securities markets at very large discounts from the prices they would command in negotiated transactions involving entire companies. Consequently, bargains in business ownership, which simply are not available directly through corporate acquisition, can be obtained indirectly through stock ownership. When prices are appropriate, we are willing to take very large positions in selected companies, not with any intention of taking control and not foreseeing sell-out or merger, but with the expectation that excellent business results by corporations will translate over the long term into correspondingly excellent market value and dividend results for owners, minority as well as majority.”


The importance and role of management when selecting companies for stock or full ownership.

”Capital Cities possesses both extraordinary properties and extraordinary management. And these management skills extend equally to operations and employment of corporate capital.  To purchase, directly, properties such as Capital Cities owns would cost in the area of twice our cost of purchase via the stock market, and direct ownership would offer no important advantages to us. While control would give us the opportunity – and the responsibility – to manage operations and corporate resources, we would not be able to provide management in either of those respects equal to that now in place. In effect, we can obtain a better management result through non-control than control. This is an unorthodox view, but one we believe to be sound.”


I thought this to be an important part to include from this letter as it discusses Banking as investments. The point he was making was that a bank does not have to be a large bank to make it a good investment. The Illinois National Bank was an excellently run small bank that was extremely profitable.

“Earnings in 1977 amounted to $3.6 million, more than achieved by many banks two or three times its size.”

 

What I have learned from this report.

  1. Warren Buffett’s investment philosophy has remained fundamentally the same today as it was decades ago.
  2. Invest in stocks where you would feel comfortable owning the entire company.
  3. Buy companies with great management; rather than thinking you can change the management yourself.
  4. Buy companies that you understand with great management, favorable long-term economics, and most importantly at great prices.
  5. Big does not always mean most profitable.

What knowledge have you gained from this report?
Leave a comment.

Berkshire Hathaway | Owner's manual Pt. 1

[Source: www.berkshirehathaway.com | Owner's manual]

Warren E. Buffett, Berkshire's Chairman, issued what he calls "An Owner's Manual" to the shareholders of Berkshire Hathaway in 1996. This booklet contains 13 economic principles to assist new shareholders to clearly understand the way Berkshire is run. Many corporations lay out corporate governance guidelines for their owners, but none has been down in a very simplified and conversational way, as Warren Buffett is typically known for. This would be a great way for new investors to learn what one should look for in great management and also understand the way Buffett thinks as well.

The owner's manual series will be divided into 3 parts. We will first concentrate on the first 3 principles of the manual in this posting and highlight key points that should be noted.

Enjoy.

Owner-Related Business Principles

1. Although our form is corporate, our attitude is partnership. Charlie Munger and I think of our shareholders as owner-partners, and of ourselves as managing partners. (Because of the size of our shareholdings we are also, for better or worse, controlling partners.) We do not view the company itself as the ultimate owner of our business assets but instead view the company as a conduit through which our shareholders own the assets.

i. Mr. Buffett and Mr. Munger both view shareholders as owner-partners. Warren Buffett truly emphasizes the importance management plays in his decisions to buy into businesses. He is no different and truly sets that example. They fully grasp and respect that shareholders are owners of public corporations and that their decisions should be based on what is ultimately best for the shareholders and disregard personal interests.

ii. They both are highly invested in the company.  They both have the majority of their net worth in Berkshire stock and is therefore, as Mr. Buffett would say, "eating their own cooking." This is an important point to consider when looking at investments. What percentage of the stock does management own? Are their interests aligned with that of the shareholders? Well, a great way to tell is if they own their own company's stock.

iii. The corporate entity does not own the business. Legally, the creation of a corporation frees management from liability. However, what Mr. Buffett is indicating in this first principle is that they view the company merely as a vehicle through which shareholders own the assets of the business. This first point alone says a lot of the management of Berkshire Hathaway and as soon as you are able to find management in other companies that exhibit the same qualities in a great business, you know that this is a company that you should look into further and buy and hold on forever. Such companies are hard to find; such management are even more rare. What he expects of shareholders as well is that they view themselves as owners that are in it for the long haul. He invests with a long term horizon and would like his shareholders to have that time horizon as well; therefore they should be willing to own the stock for the rest of their lives.

 

2. In line with Berkshire’s owner-orientation, most of our directors have a major portion of their net worth invested in the company. We eat our own cooking.

Charlie Munger's family has 90% or more of its net worth in Berkshire shares.

Warren Buffett has about 99%. His relatives also keep a large portion of their net worth 
in  Berkshire stock as well.

He continues to explain under this second principle that Berkshire Hathaway is a diversified group of quality business, and even though they are unable to guarantee results, they will make money when their shareholders make money and also lose money when their shareholders lose money.

 

3. Our long-term economic goal (subject to some qualifications mentioned later) is to maximize Berkshire’s average annual rate of gain in intrinsic business value on a per-share basis. We do not measure the economic significance or performance of Berkshire by its size; we measure by per-share progress. We are certain that the rate of per-share progress will diminish in the future — a greatly enlarged capital base will see to that. But we will be disappointed if our rate does not exceed that of the average large American corporation.

The important point to understand from this third principle is that the management of Berkshire is focused on per-share intrinsic business value gains.

Also, Mr. Buffett has been telling his shareholders for a long time that this rate of gain will decrease as the amount of capital they have to work with increases. They will have to find larger investment opportunities that will have a significant impact on the intrinsic business value.

 

4. Our preference would be to reach our goal by directly owning a diversified group of businesses that generate cash and consistently earn above-average returns on capital. Our second choice is to own parts of similar businesses, attained primarily through purchases of marketable common stocks by our insurance subsidiaries. The price and availability of businesses and the need for insurance capital determine any given year’s capital allocation.

Warren Buffett not only owns great businesses, but also owns percentages of great businesses as well. He mentions in the commentary following the fourth principle that the difficulty arises when they have too much cash on hand and not many great investment opportunities. However, he reassures us that a depressed market, [like today], provides great opportunities to buy entire businesses, or add to the ownership of the great businesses as well. These companies also repurchase their own stock in depressed markets as well, so the shareholders benefit even more.

 

For the detailed reading of The Owner's Manual, please refer to Berkshire's Hathaway's website.

Related Links:
Berkshire Hathaway | Owner’s Manual Part 4
Berkshire Hathaway | Owner’s Manual Part 3
Berkshire Hathaway | Owner’s Manual Part 2
Berkshire Hathaway | Owner’s Manual Part 1

Warren Buffett U.N.C. 1996 lecture | Part 5: Buying stocks, bank consolidations and franchise value

1996 U.N.C. Lecture Series continued...

From your point of view, what's the difference between investing in the whole company like See's Candy, or a piece of the company like The Coca Cola Company?

Warren Buffett does not believe there to be a difference in the two. The same considerations and due diligence should be made if one is seeking to invest in stock or purchase companies completely. However, the two main advantages of owning businesses Buffett highlights are:

  1. If you buy the entire company, you have the ability to change the entire management, if necessary. However, he emphasizes that he would not be buying the company if he had the change the management anyway. In previous lectures, we know how important management is to Buffett, therefore if management was not capable and honest, the company would not be an investment worthy of making. This is because he many not know anything of running the business himself. However, you do have the option of changing management at some point in time if you think this is necessary for the future success of the company.
  2. You would have the ability to take the capital of the company and allocate it appropriately. As he does with his holding company of 70+ businesses, all managers send him excess capital, and he allocates capital as he sees fit towards marketable securities or outright purchasing of companies.

Talk about banking consolidation.

"I do not see economies of scale beyond certain points. There is always an advantage to being dominant in a market, but I am not sure whether you have got $200 billion spread across the country and 15% market shares, that you are going to have a better business than someone that has 30% market share in Rockford, Illinois. We used to own a bank in Rockford, Illinois which made 2% on assets after tax and was conservative in every respect but that bank would earn less money as part of a larger institution. So, I don't see great advantages to shareholders in terms of major expansions of banks. ...The acquiring bank's shareholders will be better off in most situations than the acquirer's shareholders."

I was wondering if you comment on your perspective of investments outside of the U.S. and in particular, address how you would hedge currency risk?

" We like companies that can do well in international markets obviously, particularly where they are largely untapped. Would be buy Coca Cola, if instead of being domicile in Atlanta, it was domicile in London or Amsterdam or someplace? The answer is obviously yes. Would I like it just as well? Probably a tiny notch less. Well, there may be nuances of corporate structures or tax factors or attitudes towards capitalists that I do not quite understand as well. So I prefer, by a small margin to many countries and by a large margin to other countries, U.S. domicile operations. But I also prefer companies that earn high returns on capital. We will look any place to find a good business, and I find it easier to find them in the U.S. because I understand the economy a lot better and I understand how they would function in the future than in some other country, but I don't rule them out."

I agree with this as well. A great way to play currencies is to invest in large U.S. corporations that earn a great share of their earnings outside of the U.S. Buffett mentions a couple examples of Coca Cola and Gillette. Other examples include Johnson and Johnson, Proctor and Gamble (acquired Gillette) and Nike. These are all companies in his portfolio.

What companies do you perceive as having franchise value right now?

Warren Buffett defines it using the idea that will people be willing to pay extra for a particular product versus a cheaper alternative. Does your product create that 'share of mind' in customers head? Are they willing to go through the extra effort to purchase your product than settle for another? He then refers to franchise value as a moat around your business. These questions must be asked. How big is the moat and how durable is that moat? The moat could be based on patents, research, pricing etc. You will need a moat in business to prevent a guy from coming along and taking market share.

See the beginning of the final video for the remaining response to this question.

Enjoy!!!

Warren Buffett U.N.C. 1996 lecture | Part 3: We want partners in Berkshire.

 

More questions from the U.N.C. Lecture Series.

3. Mr. Buffett, you invest in companies with managers you say you trust and admire. I would like to know who you trust and admire in business and politics today?

He mentions CEO of Cap Cities, Tom Murphy. He also admires the great two manager combination at The Coca Cola Company, (Roberto and Don) that took the market value from $5 billion to $60 billion in about 11 years. He also includes Bill Gates. Even though he understands nothing about Microsoft's business, he has great respect for Bill Gates as a businessman.

The most important advice he gave in his response to this question is:

"I think it is crazy to work with people that make your stomach churn, and if you are in a job like that, think about changing. Working with people you don't like in a business is kind of like marrying for money, which is probably a bad idea under normal circumstance, but it's crazy if you are rich. I work with people I like, I tap dance to work everyday and work with people who are terrific."

4. Have you considered splitting the stock?

Many have asked this question of Mr. Buffett previously and Berkshire has the highest price of any company that trades on the NYSE. His response was as always classic and consistent with his previous remarks.

"At Berkshire, I want to get people as shareholders, as partners of mine, who have the same expectations, same time horizons, the same methods of measurement that I have. It's crazy to go into business with people that have entirely different expectations than you have. The only way that I can affect that, since Berkshire is a public company, is through communication and policies. Therefore, I will try to have policies so that the right kind of people with similar expectations will be attracted to the company. I would like to have people as owners who would expect to own it the rest of their lives."

Essentially he goes on to say that by not splitting the stock, he eliminates people who are in the markets to trade actively, and these are not the people he would like as partners in Berkshire.

5. Discuss some of your investment mistakes.

Buffett says that he makes the most mistakes when he has a lot of cash available. Usually cash is king, but in more recent lectures, he states that cash is only king if it is being put to good use. Cash has no value if it just sits there doing nothing; it actually loses value.

Please refer to the video for the rest of his comments.

Warren Buffett U.N.C. 1996 lecture | part 2: How to choose great businesses

Part 2:

In the rest of the lecture, he entertains questions from students. This is the part he enjoys most and challenges them to make them difficult for him. These are the questions and my commentary on his responses from the next 9 minutes of the U.N.C. lecture.

1. How is financial analysis of companies, for example Coca Cola or Nebraska Furniture Mart, done by yourself and Charlie Munger?

Warren Buffett's consistent philosophy is apparent in his response to this question. He talks about the owner, Rose Bumpkin, of Nebraska Furniture Mart and how passionate she was about the business. After meeting her, he said there was not much else that he needed to do; he was fully confident that it was a great business that will do even better over time. Therefore, his focus is always on the quality of management, as it was the first item he mentioned in this case. Buying a business that is run by honest, passionate and capable management is very important.

"I think any good investment idea can be put into one paragraph."

He then says that he buys businesses that he understands. He believes very strongly in operating within his circle of competence.

"The most important thing in terms of your circle of competence is not how large the area of it is, but how good you have defined the perimeter."

He is able to understand some kinds of simple businesses and does not make investment decisions outside of his realm of knowledge. This has also been a key to his success. Investing in businesses you don't understand is almost always a bad idea.  What does it mean to understand a business? Consider these 15 questions that Philip Fisher uses to analyze and understand companies he may want to buy:

1. Does the company have products or services with sufficient market potential to make possible a sizable increase in sales for at least several years? A company seeking a sustained period of spectacular growth must have products that address large and expanding markets.

 

2. Does the management have a determination to continue to develop products or processes that will still further increase total sales potentials when the growth potentials of currently attractive product lines have largely been exploited? All markets eventually mature, and to maintain above-average growth over a period of decades, a company must continually develop new products to either expand existing markets or enter new ones.

 

3. How effective are the company's research-and-development efforts in relation to its size? To develop new products, a company's research-and-development (R&D) effort must be both efficient and effective.

 

4. Does the company have an above-average sales organization? Fisher wrote that in a competitive environment, few products or services are so compelling that they will sell to their maximum potential without expert merchandising.

 

5. Does the company have a worthwhile profit margin? Berkshire Hathaway's BRK.B vice-chairman Charlie Munger is fond of saying that if something is not worth doing, it is not worth doing well. Similarly, a company can show tremendous growth, but the growth must bring worthwhile profits to reward investors.

 

6. What is the company doing to maintain or improve profit margins? Fisher stated, "It is not the profit margin of the past but those of the future that are basically important to the investor." Because inflation increases a company's expenses and competitors will pressure profit margins, you should pay attention to a company's strategy for reducing costs and improving profit margins over the long haul.

 

7. Does the company have outstanding labor and personnel relations? According to Fisher, a company with good labor relations tends to be more profitable than one with mediocre relations because happy employees are likely to be more productive. There is no single yardstick to measure the state of a company's labor relations, but there are a few items investors should investigate. First, companies with good labor relations usually make every effort to settle employee grievances quickly. In addition, a company that makes above-average profits, even while paying above-average wages to its employees is likely to have good labor relations. Finally, investors should pay attention to the attitude of top management toward employees.

 

8. Does the company have outstanding executive relations? Just as having good employee relations is important, a company must also cultivate the right atmosphere in its executive suite. Fisher noted that in companies where the founding family retains control, family members should not be promoted ahead of more able executives. In addition, executive salaries should be at least in line with industry norms. Salaries should also be reviewed regularly so that merited pay increases are given without having to be demanded.

 

9. Does the company have depth to its management? As a company continues to grow over a span of decades, it is vital that a deep pool of management talent be properly developed. Fisher warned investors to avoid companies where top management is reluctant to delegate significant authority to lower-level managers.

 

10. How good are the company's cost analysis and accounting controls? A company cannot deliver outstanding results over the long term if it is unable to closely track costs in each step of its operations. Fisher stated that getting a precise handle on a company's cost analysis is difficult, but an investor can discern which companies are exceptionally deficient--these are the companies to avoid.

 

11. Are there other aspects of the business, somewhat peculiar to the industry involved, which will give the investor important clues as to how outstanding the company may be in relation to its competition? Fisher described this point as a catch-all because the "important clues" will vary widely among industries. The skill with which a retailer, like Wal-Mart WMT or Costco COST, handles its merchandising and inventory is of paramount importance. However, in an industry such as insurance, a completely different set of business factors is important. It is critical for an investor to understand which industry factors determine the success of a company and how that company stacks up in relation to its rivals.

 

12. Does the company have a short-range or long-range outlook in regard to profits? Fisher argued that investors should take a long-range view, and thus should favor companies that take a long-range view on profits. In addition, companies focused on meeting Wall Street's quarterly earnings estimates may forgo beneficial long-term actions if they cause a short-term hit to earnings. Even worse, management may be tempted to make aggressive accounting assumptions in order to report an acceptable quarterly profit number.

 

13. In the foreseeable future will the growth of the company require sufficient equity financing so that the larger number of shares then outstanding will largely cancel the existing stockholders' benefit from this anticipated growth? As an investor, you should seek companies with sufficient cash or borrowing capacity to fund growth without diluting the interests of its current owners with follow-on equity offerings.

 

14. Does management talk freely to investors about its affairs when things are going well but "clam up" when troubles and disappointments occur? Every business, no matter how wonderful, will occasionally face disappointments. Investors should seek out management that reports candidly to shareholders all aspects of the business, good or bad.

 

15. Does the company have a management of unquestionable integrity? The accounting scandals that led to the bankruptcies of Enron and WorldCom should highlight the importance of investing only with management teams of unquestionable integrity. Investors will be well-served by following Fisher's warning that regardless of how highly a company rates on the other 14 points, "If there is a serious question of the lack of a strong management sense of trusteeship for shareholders, the investor should never seriously consider participating in such an enterprise."

[Source Morningstar.com]

If you are able answer all these questions about a company, which would require thorough research of course, you are well on your way to fully understanding a business.
For more information on Philip Fisher's scuttlebutt approach, I highly recommend purchasing this book; Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits.

Buffett then talks about The Coca Cola Company. He refers to this company as a business he fully understands and indicates that it is increasing market share in virtually every country it operates in. These are the items he says one should look for:
i. Look to see if the product is somewhat durable.
ii. Whether the appeal is universal and,
iii. If the company has honest management.
He says The Coca Cola Company exhibits all these characteristics.

"Peter Lynch says buy a business that's so good that any idiot can run it because sooner or later one will."

He sums up his philosophy at Berkshire Hathaway in this one quote.

"All we are trying to do is to find businesses we think we understand, where we like the people running them and the price makes sense in relation to the future economics. And when I find that, I like to buy a lot of it and keep it. And they are hard enough to find that I don't believe in selling them very often because it is hard to find replacements."

2. How do you know when to sell a business?

"The question of selling a really good business is never. To sell off something that's a really wonderful business because the price looks a little high or something is almost always a mistake. It took me a long time to learn that. If you truly believe that the long-term economics of a business is terrific, it rarely makes sense to sell it."

Great content in this clip. Enjoy.

End of Part 2.

Warren Buffett U.N.C. 1996 lecture | part 1: Qualities of character

This is undoubtedly one of my favorite videos on Warren Buffett. I have blogged about this lecture before, but I thought that the content was so amazing, that I had to break it up into pieces and really delve into the words of wisdom he imparts to these students so that we can all learn from it. I have listened to this many times, and now, I really pay attention to what he says so that I can reinforce my investment principles in this difficult, but exciting economic environment. I say exciting because this is a time where great investment opportunities can be found, as Warren indicated in his Op-Ed article in The New York Times. See my blog on this article; Buy American, I am.

So this lecture from the University of North Carolina in 1996 is divided into 6 parts. Therefore, for this series I will highlight the main content of the particular segment and allow you to pay attention to the videos to build your own knowledge on investing.

Part 1:

I will begin with part 1, where he talks about his involvement with Salomon Brothers in resolving some management issues and running the company. He was brought in to replace the current management and prevent the company from running into the ground. Therefore, he had to find someone who was qualified enough to run the company, that is, dealing with daily operations and making complex business decisions, since he would be preoccupied with regulators and such. He then gets into what was important for the students to know.

He met with 12 people, only knowing 4 of them by sight to interview for the position. This is what he looked at when considering.

He was not concerned about their grades in business school or even if they went to business school at all. He did not ask for their resumes; it did not make any difference. He knew they all had the I.Q. that was necessary to handle the job. He knew that they all were intelligent enough for the position because they could not have gotten to where they were without the understanding of the markets and how financial instruments work and so forth. He wanted to know how their machinery works. He says you can tell the people who are very full of themselves. You can detect the ones that would not have the courage in a difficult situation. He wanted people who were always willing to give others credit, or who wouldn't cut corners and who deliver all they promise and a little extra.

Warren Buffett continues to speak about the character and work ethic of the guy he hired for the position. Listen and tell me what you think about this section.

He then relays a story he always gives to students.

"If you looked under your seat today and one of you had this lucky ticket and the one with the lucky ticket got to pick one of your classmates. You had to pick one classmate and you had an hour to make the decision. You would then get 10% of the earnings of this classmate for the rest of his/her life. What would you think about in that hour? Would you think about the I.Q., the grades, who was the best looking? Probably not. A lot of things will go through your mind and you will be amazed about how you all will settle on relatively few individuals. You are not thinking about things that are impossible for you to achieve yourself. You are not thinking about who can jump seven feet, who can through a football 65 yards, who can recite Pi to 700 digits. You are thinking about a whole lot of qualities of character. The truth is, every one of those qualities is attainable. They are largely a matter of habit."

He mentioned that his old boss, Benjamin Graham, wrote down qualities that he admired in other people and qualities he found objectionable. He realized that none of the qualities he liked were not attainable. It was a matter of exhibiting those behaviors and not exhibiting the behaviors that he disliked. Warren Buffett says that this is easier to do when you are young, so he encourages the students to do so.

He ends with the following quote:

"Chains of habit are too light to be felt until they are too heavy to be broken."

End of Part 1

I decided to list some of the behaviors I admire and others I choose not to exhibit. What are some of yours? Feel free to drop a comment about them.

Behaviors I admire:
Lovingness
Honesty
Integrity
Responsible
Hard-working
Peaceful
Courageous
Respectful
Humorous

Behaviors I dislike:
Dishonesty
Hateful
Aggressiveness
Laziness
Irresponsible
Condescending
Disrespectful
Vindictive

Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 9: market cap

"It does not make any difference; large cap, small cap, giant cap, micro cap, medium cap. All that matters is that we understand the business, we like who is running it and it is selling at a price that is attractive."

This clip briefly talks about the prospects of large caps versus small caps. As the quote indicates above, Warren Buffett stated that they pay no attention to the market cap of the company with regards to one cap outperforming the other. It makes no difference. When they look at businesses, they ask three (3) questions:

1. Do we understand the business?
2. Do we like the people running it?
3. Is it selling at a price that is attractive?

As you can see, this is consistent with his basic investment philosophy.

"The cap does not make a difference; it is the certainty of the business that counts."

 

Investment Philosophy

I thought it best to reiterate the basic principles upon which Warren Buffett's philosophy lies. Given the current conditions of the economy, we cannot hear the basics enough to keep us focused.
 
1. Buy a business you understand.
2. Buy a business with favorable long-term prospects.
3. Buy a business operated by honest and competent people.
4. Buy a business available at a very attractive price.

As another one of my favorite investers, Bruce Berkowitz, said "Ignore the crowd"; this is what we should do in this environment. We know that the market is driven by sentiment and emotions, therefore stick to your underlying philosophy and do not pay attention to the noise in the market. Like the ocean when the water is rough, it is difficult to see through clouded by sand; but when the water settles and the calm is restored, only then can you see things clearly. Focus on the business; ignore the extraneous details.

Life Philosophy

It was interesting how what I am about to write came about. I could not think of a way to relate this to life, but I know there is always a way. So I took a break and now the idea came through me. Have faith. You know how normally we have faith in our beliefs once everything is going well for us, but as soon as we encounter difficult times, we are tested. Why are we tested? Well, it is during those times we are the most vulnerable and there exists a high possibility of us changing or relinquishing our belief systems. Just as this very volatile market condition or challenging economic environment has impacted most of the investors out there, we are affected in life just the same. The message I deliver is when the times get tough, this is when you should focus even more on what you believe in, because ultimately, when the dust clears, your firm understanding will get you through and all those that panicked would have missed the opportunity.






Related Posts
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 1: Integrity
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 2: Smart Choices
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 3: Choosing Businesses
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 4: Share of Mind
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 5: Circle of Competence
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 6: Macroeconomic Factors
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 7: Inactivity & Dividends
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 8: Diversification
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 9: Market Cap
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 10: Ovarian Lottery

Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 8: Diversification

"Wide diversification is only required when investors do not understand what they are doing."

In this clip, Warren Buffett talks mainly about diversification, therefore I will concentrate the content just on this topic. He also talks about the businesses of Proctor and Gamble and Coca-Cola and why they are great businesses.

Nevertheless, his response to the question on diversification was two-fold.

1. If you are not a professional investor and your goal is not to manage money so that you get a significantly better return than the world, then 98-99% of the people who invest should diversify. This is the only case where he firmly agrees with diversification. These type of investors should consider indexing.

2. However, if you want to bring intensity to the game; to make a decision and start evaluating businesses, then diversification is a bad idea. If you really know businesses, you shouldn't own more than six of them. Going into a seventh idea rather than adding to your best idea rarely makes sense.

"Diversification is insurance against ones own ignorance."

Investing Philosophy

In an effort to stick to the simplicity of this idea, I will not dwell too much on it. I think it is self explanatory. If you are a sophisticated investor, then diversification may not be necessary. However, if you are not, you should diversify. The idea of diversification to minimize risk is what MBA students are taught in universities. Any finance course will tell you that unsystematic risk is reduced after owning about 15 stocks or so in a portfolio. However, this is dependent on your definition of risk. If you truly understand a business, then this whole philosophy of risk changes. You buy great businesses you understand with great economics, management at a very attractive price; what risk would there be? If you think volatility; well that only offers the opportunity to buy more at attractive prices.

"In the short run, the stock market is a voting machine, but in the long run, it is a weighing machine."

Life Philosophy

What does his philosophy on diversification teach us? I think it says that if you are absolutely certain about something, you should not fear putting a lot into it. For example, if I have studied a company, done all that I can to  really understand the business, believe in the management, love the future economics of the company, then why should I hesitate to invest greatly in it. The returns will ultimately come. Consequently, if you truly believe in something, then give it your all, do not be afraid of risks or do not be tempted by what others may be doing, put your all in your best idea, in what you truly want to do with your life, and that is when you will be rewarded. If things do not work out the way you like, then at least you know that you did your best with it and that should be enough. Think about this greatly, diversification is almost another way of saying 'fear of failure or defeat'. Put your effort in what you truly want out of life, and chances are high that your desires will be fulfilled; you will see the returns. It just may not happen when you expect it to, but I assure you, it will happen in due time.

Check my blog posting on Napoleon Hill on The Power of the Mind.






Related Posts
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 1: Integrity
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 2: Smart Choices
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 3: Choosing Businesses
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 4: Share of Mind
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 5: Circle of Competence
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 6: Macroeconomic Factors
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 7: Inactivity & Dividends
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 8: Diversification
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 9: Market Cap
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 10: Ovarian Lottery

Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 7: Inactivity & dividends

"Wall Street makes its money on activity, you make your money on inactivity."

The opening quote for this clip of Warren Buffett's M.B.A. talk series was derived from his response when a student asked about the benefits of being an outsider of Wall Street. Buffett further states that he avoids environments that encourage too much activity, with Wall Street being the epitome of that. These environments cause over-stimulation. Ultimately, all that one needs is a single great investment a year.

Essentially, brokers make most of the money through activity. Therefore, they encourage investors to trade within their portfolios frequently. This is not needed to be a successful investor, however, being in an atmosphere like Wall Street, allows you to think otherwise.

Another student asked this question:
How can an investor value shares of Berkshire Hathaway if the company does not pay dividends?

Buffett responds:

"The question is if Berkshire can retain $1.00 in earnings and earn more than $1.00 at a decent rate. That's what they try to do."

"It is run for its owners, but not run to give them dividends because so far, every dollar we have earned and could have paid out, we have turned into more than a dollar; it is worth more than a dollar to keep it." 

Many have questioned Warren Buffett on his dividend policy, or lack thereof. I think there is a misconception where many believe that all companies should pay dividends. In studying this in graduate school, dividend payout makes the most sense when a company is unable to earn a high rate of return on retained earnings and should therefore distribute this to shareholders, so that they can do so themselves. However, Berkshire shareholders have the world's greatest investor and capital allocator investing for them, so expecting a dividend at this point in time does not make sense. And as he said, the bigger the company gets, the more difficult it is for him to invest capital, so at some point in the future, dividends may be a possibility. I am happy to have Mr. Buffett working for me, and he continues to add value and measures themselves by performance. Can't get it any better than that. 

A third student asked:
How do you know when a business has reached its full potential?

Buffett, consistent with his investing philosophy of buy and hold forever, says that they do not buy businesses with a price target in mind. The best businesses are the ones that you can hold on to forever.

"The way to look at a business is, is it going to produce more and more and more over time? If the answer to that question is yes, then you do not need to ask any more questions."

 

Investing Philosophy

When you find great businesses with excellent future economics and able and honest management, he previously mentioned that there should not be an exit strategy. These are businesses that are so rare to be found, that it makes no sense to sell them once you find them. He speaks about this on many occasions at meetings with students and frequently says that it took him a long time to understand that concept. In an age where there is so much more access to information and a constant bombardment from all sorts of media, inactivity has really become a challenge to those 'patient' investors. However, these are the investors that are most successful.

I do believe in this strategy of inactivity, but one must have truly understood the business initially, for this to hold up. On the other hand, Buffett did mention that there were times where sales were necessary; for example, in the purchase of a more appealing deal, or something drastic occurs that changes the overall dynamics of the business.

Life Philosophy

This clip reminded me of another one of Warren Buffett's famous quotes.

"We don't get paid for activity, just for being right. As to how long we'll wait, we'll wait indefinitely."

This is really a lesson in understanding what you are doing, not swaying from those principles and being patient. For such an exciting field, investing, having a certain degree of temperament is very crucial to one's success. I suppose it makes a lot of sense to be because it suites my personality. However, I do believe that investing is way more simple that it is made out to be and Warren Buffett's philosophy resonates with me because of that fact. Beyond the betas, deltas, alphas, standard deviations, models, theories, there is an underlying strategy that is simple. I agree with the principle known as Occam's Razor: The simplest answer is often correct. The same with life; life is very simple, we just make it complicated. Live a simple life and it will be reflected in all your experiences.






Related Posts
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 1: Integrity
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 2: Smart Choices
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 3: Choosing Businesses
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 4: Share of Mind
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 5: Circle of Competence
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 6: Macroeconomic Factors
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 7: Inactivity & Dividends
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 8: Diversification
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 9: Market Cap
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 10: Ovarian Lottery

Warren Buffett MBA talk | Part 3: Choosing Businesses

"Investing is putting out money to be sure of getting more money back at an appropriate rate. And to do that, you have to understand the business."

In part three of this lecture, Warren talks about what constitutes a great company. He begins by briefly stating that one should take a job one loves, then describes what he looks for in businesses he buys. This is the basic approach to investment analysis by Warren Buffett and is the foundation upon which he begins choosing businesses for the long term.

These are some of the main points of part 3 of this lecture:

1. Only do work you would enjoy.

Take a job, that if you were independently wealthy, you would take. You will get a lot more out of it and will enjoy it more.

If you think you will be happier making 2X instead of X, you are making a mistake. You ought to find something you like and you will get in trouble if you think that making 10X or 20X is the answer to everything in life because then you will do things like borrow money when you shouldn't or cut corners on things your employers want you to cut corners on. It does not make any sense; you would not like it when you look back on it.

2. Warren Buffett's business criteria

What makes companies you like?

i. Go for businesses you understand.
ii. Simple businesses, but not easy businesses.
iii. Business must have a moat.
iv. Honest, hard-working and able management.
v. Good current and future economics.

3. Moats

Buffett goes on to discuss the idea of a moat being the competitive advantage of the company. He uses the example of car insurance. Insurers compete on service and price; since most of the insurers offer similar products, the price is what he must compete on. Therefore he must be the low-cost provider. Therefore, GEICO is the low-cost provider in this industry and therefore, he owns it.

A lot of emphasis is put on the moat. He mentions to the MBA students that the one request he has for his managers is to widen the moats of their respective businesses, that is, strengthen their competitive advantages; throw in alligators and crocodiles and snakes.

Moats can come across through patents, quality of product, service, cost or real estate location.

4. Buy a business you understand

If he is not able to tell what a business will be like 10+ years from now, he is not going to buy it.

I would not buy any stock, if they closed the stock exchange tomorrow for 5 years, I won't be happy owning it.

You're buying a piece of business.

You're not buying a stock; you're buying into a business and once the business does well, you will do well.

If I were teaching a class in business school and on the final exam, I would pass out information on an Internet company and tell the students to value it. Anyone that gave me an answer would flunk. You can't do it.








Related Posts
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 1: Integrity
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 2: Smart Choices
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 3: Choosing Businesses
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 4: Share of Mind
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 5: Circle of Competence
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 6: Macroeconomic Factors
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 7: Inactivity & Dividends
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 8: Diversification
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 9: Market Cap
Warren Buffett MBA Talk | Part 10: Ovarian Lottery

FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER

Sponsored Links

Recommended Readings